Crop tolerance to soil salinity, yield and salt data under farming conditions analysed statistically.

       In the case studies below, the following references are used:
H.J. Nijland and S. El Guindy (1982), Crop yields, watertable depth and soil salinity in the Nile Delta, Egypt. In: Annual report 1983, p. 19-28. International Institute for Land Reclamation and Improvement (ILRI), Wageningen, The Netherlands.
See: Egypt article
D.P. Sharma, K.N. Singh and K.V.G.K Rao (1990), Crop Production and soil salinity: evaluation of field data from India. Paper published in Proceedings of the Symposium on Land Drainage for Salinity Control in Arid and Semi-Arid Regions, February 25th to March 2nd, 1990, Cairo, Egypt, Vol. 3, Session V, p. 373 - 383.
See: India article
R.J. Oosterbaan (1980), Crop yields, soil salinity and watertable depth in Pakistan. In: Annual Report 1981, p. 50-54. ILRI, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Reprinted in Indus 24 (1983) 2, p. 29 - 33.
See: Pakistan article
The soil salinity is expressed in electric conductivity of an extract of a saturated paste (ECe) of a soil sample in dS/m (millimho/cm).
The figures for Egypt were made with Ms Excel, those for India and Pakistan with PartReg
At the end, a summary of the crop tolerances is given.

In the annex, a comparison is made wit data of the Agricultural Experiment Sation of the Utah State University.
& models
& manuals
case studies
& answers

Crops surveyed are berseem (clover), cotton, maize (corn), rice (paddy) and wheat.
berseem (clover) and salinity in Egypt
Berseem (Egyptian clover) data were collected from 4 cuts in the winter season 1979-1980 in the villages Minyet Beni Mansur, Darawa, Mit Loza and Nizaret Fisha Balkha. The yield represents fresh green matter. ECe represents the average soil salinity over the season.
As the salinity in the region is not very high, no data are available on the yield decrease at higher ECe values. The salt tolerance of Berseem is at least 4 dS/m because the trendline through the data here is (almost) horizontal and all yields are above 10 t/ha. A sharply declining trend for ECe values > 4 cannot be seen.
cotton and 
        salinity in Egypt
The cotton yield (lint+seed) was determined in the summer of 1981 in the villages Minyet Tujh, Darawa, Mit Loza and Kafr Shubra Qallug. There are not many data with salinity ECe > 8 dS/m. The salt tolerance of cotton is possibly greater than 8 dS/m. Cotton is definitely a more than moderately tolerant crop, if not a salt resistant crop.
maize (corn) and
     salinity in Egypt  
Maize is planted in the first half of June and harvested from mid September to mid October. The grain yield of Maize was determined in 1981 in the villages Kafr Shubra, Darawa and Minyet Tukh. There are few data with salnity ECe > 6 dS/m, but from the figure it can be deduced that the tolerable salt stress of maize is 6 dS/m or higher. Maize is a moderately tolerant crop and maybe more than that.
rice (paddy) and
     salinity in Egypt
The rice is of the short grain (Japonica) type. Rice nurseries are prepared in May and transplantation occurs in June. Harvest is in October. The grain yields were collected in 1981 and 1982 in the village Mit Loza. As the number of data with salinity ECe > 7 dS/m is small, the salt tolerance of rice cannot be exactly found, but it is at least 6 dS/m. Up to that point the trendline is slightly, but insignicantly, sloping upward. Rice is certainly a moderately tolerant crop, if not more than that.

wheat and
       salinity in Egypt  
The grain yield of wheat was collected in the winter season 1981-1982 in the villages Mit Loza, Kafr Shubra Qallug and Nizaret Fisha Balkha. Like for Berseem, the number of data with high soil salinity (> 12 dS/m) is scarce so that the salt resistance of wheat cannot be precisely determined. The figure suggests that the tolerable salt stress of wheat is at least 7 or 8 dS/m because up to that point there is no significantly descending trend. Wheat appears to be a more than moderately tolerant crop.

Crops surveyed are wheat (2x), mustard (rapeseed) and barley.
wheat and salinity in Sampla
In contrast to the previous examples, here there were enough data with ECe beyond the tolerance threshold to be able to detect precisely where the initially horizontal trend in the relation between yield and salinity changes into a downward trend. The maximum salt tolerance of wheat in Sampla is 4.9 (say 5) dS/m before it starts to be affected negatively when the ECe increases more. This wheat crop is moderately sensitive to salt.
wheat and salinity in Gohana
The wheat data of Gohana show a higher salt tolerance (threshold salinity ECe=7dS/m) than the Sampla data. The reason is unknown. The average yield below the breakpoint is somewhat less, and the variation of the yield is higher. The slope of the regression line through the data below the breakpoint is very small and insignificant, so it might be concluded that there is no effect of salinity on the yield up to the threshold. However, owing to the high variation, it might be argued that the tolerance threshold could be 6 instead of 7 dS/m. Anyway, the wheat in Gohana can be called salt tolerant.
mustard and salinity in Sampla
It is a characteristic of most field data collected in small plots on the yield - salinity relation that they show considerable scatter. Mustard is no exception. Yet, the salt tolerance of mustard in the above graph shows consistently and systematically lower yields at ECe level greater than 8 compared to the yields at lower ECe levels. In this example there is a pronounced discontinuity, a sudden jump, in yields to the left and to the right of the threshold. So it can be safely concluded that mustard is "quite tolerant".
barley and salinity in Sampla
Barley, like cotton, is generally known as a salt tolerant crop. The following figure confirms this property with a threshold value of 8.9 (say 9), which proves that this crop is "quite tolerant". This barley is apparently grown in saline lands as there are many observations in the range of ECe = 10 to 25 dS/m. The random selection of plots proves that the average salinity is greater than that at the breakpoint. It seems that farmers accept a somewhat lower yield, probably because there is no alternative land use and the barley still provides them with some income.

Crops surveyed are sorghum and cotton.
sorghum and salinity in Pakistan
The yield of sorghum is not negatively affected by soil salinity up to a salinity level of ECe=8.5 dS/m. Beyond that point a sharp yield decline occurs with increasing ECe values. According to the generally accepted classification, this sorghum is a salt tolerant and may even be called "quite tolerant" or "salt resistant".
cotton and salinity in Pakistan
In cotton, up to ECe=17 no significant yield decline can be detected. Thereafter a sharply declining trend manifests itself. Doubt may arise as to the robustness of the breakpoint on grounds of the limited number of data with an ECe value greater than 14. However, the statement that the tolerable salt stress is higher than 12 will probably not meet with much resistance. This cotton crop, according to the widely accepted classification, is very tolerant to soil salinity.

      in ECe (dS/m)  
Berseem, Nile Delta, Egypt     2.4     Sensitive
Cotton, Nile Delta, Egypt     8.0     Tolerant
Maize, Nile Delta, Egypt     5.5     Moderately tolerant
Rice, Nile Delta, Egypt     5.5     Moderately tolerant
Wheat, Nile Delta, Egypt     7.5     Tolerant
Barley, Sampla, India     8.9     Tolerant
Mustard, Sampla, India     7.9     Tolerant
Wheat, Sampla, India     4.9     Moderately tolerant
Wheat, Gohana, India     7.1     Moderately tolerant
Sorghum, Khairpur, Pakistan     10.5     Very tolerant
Cotton, Khairpur, Pakistan     17.5     Extremely tolerant

See also the article that appeared in the International Journal of Agricultural Science, entitled: Crop Tolerance to Soil Salinity, Statistical Analysis of Data Measured in Farm Lands.

On the left side a graph is shown as presented in Bulletin 335 (p. 36) of the Agricultural Experiment Station of the Utah State University.
On the right side one can see what PartReg makes of the data of site C.

sorghum and salinity in Pakistan
  cotton and salinity in Pakistan  

Utah uses an exponential curve and therefore misses the tolerance level, which is actually quite high.